MUDWTR vs RYZE vs Cuppa— Which Mushroom Coffee Wins?
For many of us, coffee is a daily crutch. One cup to wake up, another to power through the morning, and yet another guilty cup when energy dips.
But while coffee delivers a boost, it can come with consequences. Too much caffeine leaves many of us overstimulated and frazzled, or crashing hard within hours.
As self-confessed coffee addicts, our editors went looking for a smart solution and discovered mushroom coffee. It sounded like the perfect alternative: less caffeine, grounded energy, and bonus functional benefits.
But with three major brands dominating the market (MUDWTR’s Coffee, Cuppa’s Healthy Coffee, and RYZE’s Dark Roast), we had to dig deeper. So we put each brand’s bestsellers to the test.
MUDWTR Review
MUDWTR provides a calm energy experience that also supports mental clarity, energy, focus and gut health without the negative effects of high caffeine.
Their Coffee combines a novel blend of 2,250 mg of functional mushrooms, including Lion’s Mane (focus), Cordyceps (physical stamina and energy), L-Theanine (calm focus and reduce jitters or anxiety), and Chaga and Reishi (immunity and stress support).
On top of that, it starts with a novel blend of Arabica and Swiss Water® decaffeinated coffee, delivering a full-bodied flavor and aroma with just 45 mg of caffeine, using a gentle, chemical-free process that relies only on water, time, and temperature.
Flavor-wise, MUDWTR’s Coffee offers a richly layered taste that’s super comforting. Smooth and balanced, it’s marvelous for a mindful morning ritual.
RYZE Review
RYZE Dark Roast Mushroom Coffee has a simple formula that focuses solely on mushrooms and has few other holistic ingredients.
It combines Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps, Reishi, and Turkey Tail (gut health) and Shiitake (immunity) with 90mg of caffeine. So rather than a full coffee replacement, it’s a daily upgrade.
Taste-wise, RYZE is mildly creamy, with subtle hazelnut notes.
For those easing off traditional coffee who want a quick boost, RYZE works—but without L-theanine, its 90 mg of caffeine can come with a crash or jitters. For a smoother, longer-lasting energy that comes with mushroom coffee, go with a beverage like MUDWTR.
Cuppa Review
Cuppa’s Healthy Coffee blends 100% Arabica coffee with 2,000 mg of mushrooms, including Lion’s Mane, Ashwagandha (stress relief), Cordyceps, L-Theanine, plus MCT and fiber for gut health.
It uses fruiting body extracts, which means it doesn’t leave any sediment in the cup—making it a smoother experience for those sensitive to texture. In contrast, MUDWTR uses whole mushroom powders, including both mycelium and fruiting bodies, offering the full spectrum of mushroom benefits.
Flavor-wise, it tastes like coffee, but without the energy dips. Cuppa is fine if you want coffee with some brain, mood, and stress support. But if you’re looking for a mushroom-heavy boost and lower caffeine, look elsewhere.
Key Similarities:
- All are coffees with functional mushrooms, designed for sustained energy and concentration
- Each contains functional mushrooms like Lion’s Mane, with some leveraging the powers of Chaga, Cordyceps, and Reishi
- Low-caffeine formulations provide a laid-back vibe — designed to promote steadier energy with less likelihood of jitters or midday slumps.
- Wellness benefits include digestive support and mental clarity
- All offer money-back guarantees, reducing risk for new users
Key Differences:
Ingredients & formulation
- MUDWTR Coffee has the most diverse and transparent blend, combining key functional ingredients like Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps, Chaga, Reishi, and L-Theaninewith Swiss Water Decaf Coffee.
- RYZE Dark Roast blends Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps, Reishi, Turkey Tail, and Shiitake mushrooms with caffeine.
- Cuppa Healthy Coffee blends 100% Arabica coffee with Lion’s Mane, Ashwagandha, L-Theanine, Cordyceps, MCT, and fiber.
Caffeine Content
- MUDWTR contains around 45 mg per serving, and features Arabica coffee and Swiss Water Decaf.
- RYZE Dark Roast comes in slightly higher at about 90 mg due to its coffee base
- Cuppa contains real 100% Arabica coffee with 70 mg of caffeine content
Mushroom Quantity & Transparency
- MUDWTR focuses on four key mushrooms in a more potent, effective dose — around 2,250 mg per serving (563mg Lion’s Mane, 536mg Cordyceps, 563mg Chaga, 563mg Reishi)
- RYZE includes six different mushrooms, totaling 2,000 mg per serving—about 333 mg of each mushroom per serving.
- Cuppa uses 2,000 mg of mushroom extracts per serving
Flavor Profile
- MUDWTR: Smooth, bold, and aromatic—crafted for your daily ritual
- RYZE: Creamy and mild, with a lighter coffee taste
- Cuppa: Strongest traditional coffee taste with an earthy aroma
Certification
- MUDWTR is completely USDA organic
- Both RYZE’s Dark Roast and Cuppa’s Healthy Coffee aren’t
Final Thoughts
After checking out RYZE and Cuppa, MUDWTR won us over due to its effective doses of mushrooms, especially the key varieties that support energy and focus, along with its fantastic taste.
While MUDWTR uses a blend of coffee and decaf for smoother, longer-lasting energy, RYZE Dark Roast contains 90 mg of caffeine, and Cuppa uses 70 mg of 100% Arabica coffee—both of which may be more likely to cause jitters for those sensitive to caffeine.
MUDWTR puts transparency and quality at the forefront — using 100% organic, vegan, gluten-free, non-GMO, and USA-grown ingredients.
The MUDWTR Starter Kit includes a rechargeable frother, a 45-day trial to the Open Mindfulness app, and a 30-day satisfaction guarantee, so first-time users can try it with no worries.
Starts at only $1.33 per serving, it’s waayyy cheaper than that triple-dipple, mocha cap at your local café. If you’re stuck in the same vicious coffee loop (wired, tired, and fried), this is a sign to try MUDWTR. It’s the coffee experience you crave — with benefits that actually work.
Special Offer For Our Readers: Get 43% Off MUDWTR Today
