FILM

You Can't Change My Mind: "A Clockwork Orange" Is Pointless at Best

Stanley Kubrick's controversial classic is a masterclass in filmography, soundtracking, and set design. But the film carries a dangerous message that's too often overlooked.

By Bart Sherkow - Shutterstock

Over the past year, I've used my increased time indoors to my advantage by catching up on a plethora of films that have been widely considered "classics."

I still have a lot of movies left to watch, but I've seen enough to know what I do and don't enjoy. I like sharp, heartfelt comedies. I like dramas that will make me cry. I like realistic love stories. I love coming-of-age movies with an edge. I enjoy surrealism, horror, and psychological thrillers — especially in a dystopian setting where critiques of the government or humanity as a whole are involved.

I didn't know much about A Clockwork Orange before I recently decided to watch it for the first time, but from the small details I'd heard about it, I'd figured Stanley Kubrick's 1971 "masterpiece" would be right up my alley.

Adapted from Anthony Burgess' novel of the same name, A Clockwork Orange follows a young man named Alex DeLarge (Malcolm McDowell), who lives in a near-future dystopian London. Alongside a small pack of like-minded companions he calls his "droogs," Alex delights in overt violence, rape, and Beethoven's Ninth Symphony.

(Warning: spoilers ahead, as well as descriptions of sexual assault.)

For the majority of my first watch of A Clockwork Orange, without knowing the ending, I was sold. I don't need to explain why Kubrick's direction is legendary across the board; there's a reason why the "Kubrick Stare" never gets old.

He's infamous for his perfectionism, and at the risk of exhausting (or even injuring) his actors, it pays off in the end. The set design is immaculate, especially considering the film was made on a fairly low budget.

A Clockwork Orange | Masterpiece Trailer | Warner Bros. Entertainmentwww.youtube.com


And speaking of budget, a good portion of it went to acquiring the rights to "Singin' in the Rain," which Malcolm McDowell improvised under Kubrick's direction to make the first rape scene even more terrifying. From the synth score to the unnerving usages of well-known classical compositions, everything about A Clockwork Orange's artistry succeeds at lulling you into its unimaginably twisted universe.

In the decades since the release of A Clockwork Orange, its core meaning has been hotly debated. (I should disclose that I haven't read the novel, although the movie stays pretty true to the original story.)

Is it a film about prison reform? About whether or not evilness can be cured? About the dangers of aversion therapy? About the sinister implications of drinking plain dairy milk?

Some of my favorite directors are those whose films can be interpreted a myriad of ways, such as David Lynch or Robert Altman. I typically welcome the challenge of a film ending that leaves me with more questions than answers. But the only question that A Clockwork Orange left me with was: "That's it?"

After Alex undergoes the infamous Ludovico technique and is released from aversion therapy, not only is he repulsed by violence and sex, but he discovers that all his belongings have been sold and his parents have rented his childhood bedroom to another young man. He can't even stand his favorite song, Beethoven's Ninth, and he ends up nearly beaten to death by his former "droogs."

Finally, Alex isn't just watching some brutal videotapes with his eyes pried open for hours at a time; he has a first-hand experience at some of the terror he previously enacted on others, and the things that once brought him joy now drive him to contemplating suicide. The viewer is led to believe that Alex might actually be properly punished for his past nauseating lifestyle.

But any hope for a proper, ethical character arc for Alex is eradicated in the film's final minutes. After his suicide attempt, he wakes up in the hospital, realizing that his aversion to violence and sex has waned. The Interior Minister who originally wanted to perform the Ludovico technique on Alex comes into his hospital room, apologizes, and offers him a job in return for support during the next election. Then, Alex narrates the film's immortalized final line as he imagines himself having sex in front of an applauding crowd: "I was cured, all right!"

The general consensus among viewers seems to be that "cured," in Alex's case, refers to the relief he feels upon realizing that he's returned to his original "ultra-violent" self; the pain he endured in futile attempts to change his ways were in vain. Either his wickedness is so deeply ingrained that it could never possibly leave him, or a change in lifestyle must be enacted by his own free will — not the product of a corrupted government rehabilitation system.

In the book's final chapter — which Kubrick decided to omit from the movie — Alex, years later, decides to lead a fairly "normal" life and start a family. The story that Kubrick chooses to tell is that of inherent evil, in which one of the most immoral characters imaginable doesn't receive adequate punishment for the harm he caused. Because, let's be real, even a corneal injury is a slap on the wrist compared to brutal rape.

Some people are of the belief that rape should be left out of films, but I'm not one of those people. I believe art is a reflection of real life, and as long as rape happens in real life, it's fair game to use as a plot device. But as a woman myself with her fair share of poor encounters with men, I find the way women are depicted in A Clockwork Orange to be unnecessarily gross. Aside from the minor roles of Alex's mom and the doctor at Mr. Alexander's house, women are treated as props throughout the film. And, of course, all the women Alex interacts with are white with "desirable" bodies.

We see violence against women frequently in film, particularly in horror and thriller movies. When depicted with adequate nuance and context, it can evoke the right emotions: For example, in David Lynch's Twin Peaks prequel film, Fire Walk with Me, we see firsthand the emotional, psychological, and physical effects that years of sexual abuse has imposed on the protagonist, Laura Palmer. We see how this abuse has troubled her relationships with her family, her boyfriend, and her best friends, and how it eventually led her to dangerous habits as a coping mechanism.

A Clockwork Orange never grants its female characters the same empathy. Sure, we hear them scream, but the screenplay doesn't allow us to understand the trauma that Alex inevitably inflicts on them. It can be argued that Kubrick does this so that we see the film from Alex's strictly sociopathic point of view.

But, when everyone from David Bowie to Lady Gaga to real,actual children have replicated Alex DeLarge's quintessential aesthetic, I have to worry that those who've identified with him in some way or another have missed the point of Anthony Burgess' story entirely — whatever point that might be.

Of course, I say all this with the understanding that film is subjective, and what clicks for one person might not click for the next. Nothing I say is going to rob A Clockwork Orange from its status as a cinematic classic, and I don't mean any ill will among those who enjoy the film.

But, in an era when we're reevaluating much of cultural history, I write this with a final proposition: If we've gotten to a point where we can shun real-life Hollywood abusers, maybe it's time to start rethinking the value we place on abusive fictional characters, too.

FILM

The 5 Best Banned Movies of All Time

Being told you can't watch a movie only makes you want to watch it more.

Media Blasters

While most movies are intended to be enjoyed by mainstream audiences, some movies are made to be transgressive.

As a result, some of our most infamous films tend to get banned in certain countries. Plenty of transgressive movies use sex and violence for shock value, existing solely for the intent of stomping on taboos and upsetting audiences. But sometimes, incredibly graphic movies like these serve a greater purpose, using taboo imagery as a means of holding up a mirror to society.

Every movie on this list has been banned at some point in one country or more for breaking societal conceptions of "decency." Every movie on this list is also very good and absolutely worth watching (provided one can handle them, of course):

A Clockwork Orange

clockwork orangeWarner Bros.

Stanley Kubrick's adaptation of Anthony Burgess' novel, A Clockwork Orange, features a protagonist who commits unthinkably evil acts including rape and "ultra-violence." But the violence serves a larger narrative, revolving around an experimental aversion therapy technique that essentially takes free will away from criminals in order to rehabilitate them. Thus, A Clockwork Orange explores themes of morality and redemption, ultimately asking whether or not taking free will away from a bad person is "wrong" if it means they can behave as functional members of society.

Battle Royale

battle royaleToei Company

Having inspired an entire genre of video games (literally, "battle royale") and an incredibly successful, super-watered down rip-off franchise (The Hunger Games), Battle Royale is one of the most influential movies in pop culture history. The premise is simple: In a dystopian Japan, a middle school class is taken to an island and forced to kill each other off until only one person is left alive. It's not hard to understand why a movie about children killing each other would be considered controversial, but the execution is excellent and provides one of the greatest thought exercises in all of film: What would you do in a battle royale?

Natural Born Killers

natural born killersWarner Bros.

Following Woody Harrelson and Juliette Lewis as a couple who go on a killing spree, Natural Born Killers might seem like a particularly disturbing concept for a black comedy. And yet, Natural Born Killers is very funny. It's definitely also disturbing. Director Oliver Stone combines bizarre visuals, graphic violence, and sharp dialogue to create a cutting social commentary that satirizes American media's fetishization of murderers.

Dead Alive

Dead AliveTrimark Pictures

Possibly one of the goriest movies ever made, Peter Jackson's pre-Lord of the Rings slapstick zombie comedy is as funny as it is disgusting. Very much so. The violence is ridiculously over-the-top, with Jackson flexing his practical effects muscles at every turn. One particular scene involving a lawnmower will likely go down as the single greatest zombie-killing scene in movie history. For anyone who enjoys gross-out humor and lots of (very fake) gore, Dead Alive has stood the test of time.

Ichi the Killer

Media Blasters

Directed by prolific Japanese auteur Takashi Miike, Ichi the Killer commonly shows up on lists of the most disturbing movies ever made. This distinction is certainly deserved due to the movie's graphic depictions of violence, both sexual and otherwise, but many people fail to recognize the function of the violence. In Ichi the Killer the violent imagery is both brutal and shocking, but sometimes it also transcends into the realm of humor––violence so awful that we have to laugh. The result is a movie that implicates viewers in the violence, forcing audiences to question their own enjoyment of such horrific imagery. For those who can stomach it, Ichi the Killer provides one of the most unique viewing experiences in all of film.