Are These Artists Actually Clones Created by Greedy Music Industry Executives?

Is Ariana Grande just a renovated Mariah Carey? Are Brendan Urie and Patrick Stump dating—or are they the same person? The truth is out there.

Though all music borrows in some way from other music, sometimes bands or artists just sound and/or look uncannily similar to each other.

These similarities raise pressing questions: how and why do these bands sound so alike? Could there be some dark secret behind their successes, some cloning initiative launched once music industry executives realized they could just repackage the same artist under a different name and double their profits?

Regardless of how much of the truth you're willing to see, this list exposes pairs of bands or artists that not only sound the same but also seem to occupy the same cultural purpose, performing the same symbolic and emotional roles for fans everywhere.

1. Cage the Elephant and the Black Keys

Cage the Elephant and the Black Keys are different bands. It's a proven fact. And yet are they? They both feature singers with mid-range voices and vaguely Southern drawls. They both use grungy guitars that sound like they've been filtered through a litany of overdrive pedals. They both make songs that have lyrics—but are the songs really about anything, or are they both just kind of sad attempts to fill the hole created by rock and roll's death?

Objective facts tell us that these bands are indeed different—Cage the Elephant opened for the Black Keys on several tours, and Black Keys frontman Dan Auerbach produced Cage the Elephant's 2015 album and their new 2019 single. But is it so hard to believe that some rip in the fabric of the time-space continuum created a world in which two slightly different iterations of the exact same band can walk around at the same time? Even some of their biggest hits like "Gold on the Ceiling" and "Ain't No Rest for the Wicked" are eerily similar, both relying on ominous bass lines and sparse, punchy guitar hits.

The Black Keys - Gold On The Ceiling [Official Music Video] www.youtube.com

Cage The Elephant - Ain't No Rest For The Wicked (Official Music Video) www.youtube.com

2. Mariah Carey and Ariana Grande

They both have stratospheric ranges, prima donna pop culture royalty and/or meme status, and impressive whistle tones. Sure, Ariana's music is tailored to the ultramodern era, whereas Mariah's occupied a similar space in the late 90's and early 2000's pop canon, but they both embody the image of the magnetic, radiant, super-talented starlet with an only slightly infuriating trail of number one hits.

Mariah Carey Vs. Ariana Grande SAME AGE Vocal Battle! (UPDATED) www.youtube.com

3. America and Neil Young

If you've heard the band America's number one hit, A Horse With No Name, chances are you might have wondered if you were listening to one of Neil Young's early collaborative efforts. But Young and Dan Peek, the late lead singer of America, share little else than a slightly nasal tenor voice, a penchant for dreamy folk rock, and dozens of harmony-laden albums from the 1970s.

America - A Horse With No Name+Lyrics www.youtube.com

Neil Young - Harvest Moon www.youtube.com

4. Radiohead and Muse

They're both obsessed with technology, paranoia, apocalypses, and thematically complex concept albums. Ultimately Radiohead's breadth and range of sonic textures far outdoes Muse's, but on some of their better-known songs, Thom Yorke and Matt Bellamy's desperate and wailing voices could easily be mistaken for one another, especially when they're both crying on about fear and loneliness in the digital era over dizzying layers of synthesizer. Plus, it would fit well with both of these bands' brands if they were replicants of each other.

How Much Does Muse Sound Like Radiohead: Analysing Composition, Style, and the Radiohead Zeitgeist www.youtube.com

5. Fleet Foxes and Grizzly Bear

Grizzly Bear and Fleet Foxes both have a propensity for multi-layered trippy, ambient folk. Their lead singers have high, delicate voices that sound like they're emanating from a distant cabin, wafting towards you on waves of campfire smoke. There's a whole battalion of folk bands that sound like these two, but as pillars of the genre, the similarities between indie's leading foxes and bears are difficult to ignore.

I'm Losing Myself (Feat. Ed Droste) by Robin Pecknold www.youtube.com

6. Fall Out Boy and Panic! at the Disco

Patrick Stump and Brendon Urie both have irrationally massive vocal ranges, which they use to create passionate, angsty, climactic jams that have been giving voice to tween girls' pain for decades. They actually have collaborated several times—even on a Coke ad, which you can listen to in its full glory as each of these singers attempts to out-belt the other. Both bands formed within three years of each other (Fall Out Boy in 2001, Panic! in 2004) and occupied similar cultural spaces in their respective golden years. Fans have even shipped the two lead singers together. Plus their specific vocal styles spawned dozens of shaggy-haired copycat frontmen.

Drunk History: Fall Out Boy featuring Brendon Urie of Panic! At The Disco www.youtube.com

Fall Out Boy Ft Brendon Urie from Panic! at the Disco - Don't Stop Believing cover www.youtube.com

7. Avril Lavigne Pre and Melissa Vandella

Everybody knows that Avril Lavigne died and was replaced by a clone of herself, created by deft industry people who couldn't resist the potential profits of more Sk8r Bois. Still, the clone does sound and look remarkably similar to her predecessor, despite the obvious differences (Melissa prefers dresses and skirts, while Avril favored pants; and Avril would never have married Chad from Nickelback). Very impressive, music industry executives, but we're onto you.

Conspiracies: Did Avril Lavigne Die in 2003? | Pigeons & Planes Update www.youtube.com

Eden Arielle Gordon is a writer and musician from New York. Follow her on Twitter @edenarielmusic.

POP⚡DUST |

The Weird, Heartless Magic of Marie Kondo: The Cleanest Cult To Ever Exist

"Love, Dust, and Robots" Is a Master Class in Short Film

Chet Faker Is Back, But He's Not Chet Faker Anymore

Culture Feature

Dear White People: AAVE Is an Actual Dialect, Not Your "Stan Culture"

Using a Black dialect isn't a meme—it's cultural appropriation.

As Black Lives Matter protests have rightfully taken the world by storm over the past couple of months, we're long overdue for thorough evaluations of just how often aspects of Black heritage have been co-opted by white audiences.

It should be obvious that much of fashion and music as we know it today was invented by Black people. We (hopefully) all know by now that we can no longer accept Blackface and use of the n-word by non-Black people as the norm—and Internet users have tried "canceling" offenders in the public eye, with varying degrees of success.

Keep Reading Show less

Watch the video for MUSE's epic new single "Dig Down"

MUSIC VIDEO | The band kicks off their summer tour with arena-shaking new music and a triumphant video


"Dig Down" starts the summer with an explosive new video.

Fed up with the negativity in the atmosphere, Muse have launched themselves back into their ionospheric comfort zone with a brand new, gospel-influenced arena rock anthem called "Dig Down." The single is their first new music since 2015's Drones and channels the electronic leanings of "Madness" for a retro-futuristic rallying cry.

The song starts with a familiar synth to anyone who's sung along to Muse's 2012 hit, "Madness," off The 2nd Law. But "Dig Down" replaces a love story in the majestic style of Queen with a triumphant follow-up to the story of rebellion on Drones. Matt Bellamy pauses his guitar while a gospel-inspired choir backs his always soaring voice. Dominic Howard and Chris Wolstenholme hold back significantly from what fans might be expecting to emphasize the simplicity of the song and the urgency of the lyrics.

Bellamy said that he wanted this song to "counteract the current negativity in the world and give inspiration, optimism and hope to people to fight for the causes they believe in." In the usual Muse style, the song broadly but grandly takes on the crises of the current moment. Here, it's the creeping feeling of doom.

"When God decides to look the other way and a clown takes the throne," Bellamy sings in the song's most specific reference to current events, "We must find a way." When asked on Twitter if he'll write a song about Trump, he alluded to this line, replying, "Only a 2nd verse."

The video explores the "Aftermath" world of Drones as Lauren Wasser, model and activist, escapes a reverse-Resident Evil–style skyscraper. After a few minutes of dragging herself through scorched debris and flickering lights, with Bellamy singing from glitching television screens, Wasser finds the elevator and prepares to escape.

It's when the elevator doors open at the ground floor that the video explodes into action. Over a full minute of single-take fighting follows. While the camera pans slowly left, Wasser battles her way through opponents, punching, kicking, flipping and rolling with the grace of a Hollywood action star.

The video captures the sci-fi fascination of Bellamy's songwriting, always aiming for the monumental in Muse's songs and albums. From "Knights of Cydonia" to "Citizen Erased," the scope of the music consistently matches the scope of his ambitions. "We're not giving up on the album at all," he told KROQ, indicating that "Dig Down" would have a place on the band's next album.

Muse. (Facebook)

Bellamy said that a new album is still in the early, conceptual stages, but that he has a theme in mind and that we'll hear four or five songs before it comes out. Drones had the most explicit plot of a Muse album yet, so we'll see if the band returns with another narrative LP or one that's more like their early albums. With no certainty about when new songs might be released (other than speculation that the album will drop next year), fans' best chance to hear new music is to buy tickets for their summer tour.

Wolstenholme on bass. (Facebook)

Muse opened the tour in Florida this weekend, beginning the show with "Dig Down" and plunging into a set that spanned most of their career. With guests 30 Seconds To Mars and opener PVRIS, Muse will play 25 more shows between now and September. See the full schedule below.

"Dig Down" represents a kind of step back into the band's electronic progression after Drones acted as a classic rock throwback and a reminder that, beneath all of the epic orchestration and bubbling synths, the band can rock. Muse are out to prove that, against all the odds, they'll dig down and find a way.

Follow Muse on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram.

MUSE Summer 2017 TOUR:

6/3: Nashville, Ascend Amphitheater

6/4: Cincinnati, Bunbury Festival

6/6: Atlanta, Lakewood Amphitheater

6/8: New Orleans, Bold Sphere at Champions Square

6/10: Austin, austin360 Amphitheater

6/12: Kansas City, Starlight Theater

6/13: St. Louis, Hollywood Casino Amphitheatre

6/15: Charlotte, PNC Music Pavilion

6/18: Dover, Firefly Festival

7/15: Ottawa, Canada, RBC Bluesfest

7/16: Québec, Canada, Festival d'été de Québec

7/18: Toronto, Canada, Budweiser Stage

7/22: Wantagh, NY, Nikon at Jones Beach Theater

8/1: Burgettstown, PA, KeyBank Pavilion

8/3: Chicago, Lollapalooza

8/5: Montreal, Canada, Osheaga Festival Musique et Arts

8/23: Leeds, England, Leeds Festival

8/27: Reading, England, Reading Festival

9/15: San Francisco, Shoreline Amphitheatre

9/16: San Diego, KAABOO DEL MAR

9/18: Morrison, Red Rocks Amphitheatre

9/20: Salt Lake City, USANA Amphitheatre

9/23: Las Vegas, Life Is Beautiful Festival


Preview | LIFE aims to dismantle modern society on debut album 'Popular Music'

RADIOHEAD announce special edition 'OK Computer' with unreleased songs

Mysterious band Superorganism returns with weirdly fun "It's All Good"