Unfortunately, New York Magazine overlooked the depth of those underneath the makeup, even dwindling some down to a footnote.
When New York Magazine began releasing photos of international drag sensations, many fans were excited to read profiles on the artistic geniuses.
Unfortunately, Vulture's coverage reminded many that a RuPaul's Drag Race bubble exists and not everyone respects the Queens for the artists they are. Instead of treating the magazine's cover stars like those prior, the publication ranked the performers, classifying them as either Top Tier or Bottom Tier. The reductive representation offered no further insight on the fascinating queens—who they are beyond surface level accomplishments or individual placements on the show. While Drag Race is a launchpad for hundreds of queens, Vulture failed to appreciate the profundity of the new generation of Instagram and reality TV celebrities.
The lives of drag performers tend to be disregarded, with fans favoring the spectacle and on-stage characters. This is a reminder that queens embody a type of expression that both embraces and rejects gender to cultivate a new narrative and understanding of personhood. Drag culture is a celebration of self and the ability we have to truly be ourselves. Unfortunately, Vulture overlooked the depth of those underneath the makeup, even dwindling some down to a dehumanizing footnote.
Queens photographed for the publication reacted swiftly, taking to Twitter to criticize the written content and the photos' lighting.
Hey everyone! As someone who has never written a news article or even have any experience in journalism, I decided… https://t.co/XBNhRQJG6e— Kim Chi (@Kim Chi)1560238459.0
Although Martin Schoeller is known for his up close, unedited style, the article did not match the quality of the photos. Willam Belli (of Drag Race and television fame) called out the journalistic integrity of Vulture's editors, claiming none of the subjects were informed they would be ranked.
@evanrosskatz No one told us they were gonna be ranking us but hey press is press. @vulture— Willam (@Willam)1560171855.0
Dear New York Magazine. Why?— Black Lives Still Matter (@Black Lives Still Matter)1560196076.0
Also @vulture. . . Why?— Black Lives Still Matter (@Black Lives Still Matter)1560196507.0
If journalists bothered to look beyond the accessible information on a drag queen's career, each artist's influence on our cultural consciousness would be more recognized. In turn, they could become championed members of our society, surpassing Pride coverage and queer-oriented events (ahem Met Gala). Uplifting their stories year round (outside of the reality show format) would increase the number of pivotal voices allowed to transform our culture. If it wasn't obvious enough, these entertainers have contributed to a shift in Western society and impacted younger generations for good: Gen Y and Z are more inclusive and expressive than past generations, which will inform the future, with or without journalistic appreciation. Vulture should know better.
- WEEKLY RUCAP | The Finale to end all Finales - Popdust ›
- Courtney Love Runs Wild In Her Glittery New Music Video 'You ... ›
- Don't Trust the Elderly in the "It Chapter Two" Trailer - Popdust ›
- "RuPaul's Drag Race All-Stars" Season 4 Queens - Popdust ›
- Lizzo Releases Colorful New "Juice" Video - Popdust ›
- How Black Drag Queens Invented Camp: An Incomplete History of ... ›
- Countering the Whitewashing of Pride - Popdust ›
- 7 Film and TV Shows From 2019 to Celebrate Pride Month - Popdust ›
- On The Cover: The Most Powerful Drag Queens in America -- New ... ›
- The Most Powerful Drag Queens in America, Ranked ›
- Pride Month Resource Kit for Journalists | GLAAD ›
- Pride Month 2019 Marks the Stonewall 50th Anniversary: The ... ›
- Ginger Minj's Pride Month Herstory Lesson On Gladys Bentley: Watch ›
- NYC Pride Events 2019: Every Gay Pride Month Parade, March ... ›